A company gets to the job offer after several weeks of searching, with one or two finalists left, meaning candidates who have passed every stage of selection. Yet the offer itself is often made on the fly: a call saying “we’re ready to bring you on,” the terms spread over three chat messages, and a reply requested “whenever you can.” This is exactly the step where one of the most expensive losses in hiring happens: the finalist says “no,” or says “yes” and never shows up for work.
This article is for an owner or manager who hires without a recruiter. It lays out the steps from the decision to the first working day: what to find out before the offer, what to put in the letter, what deadlines to set, how to talk about money, and what to do while the person hasn’t started yet.
Why offers get turned down and what it costs
Some rejections have nothing to do with how attractive the company is and everything to do with the process: the company took too long to decide, the terms weren’t what the candidate expected, or the letter left out what had been promised verbally. These are causes the company controls itself.
There is little public Ukrainian data on what share of offers gets accepted. The recruitment agency ITExpert analyzed 315 offers made to mid- and senior-level IT specialists (published July 2, 2025): 79% were accepted, meaning candidates turned down roughly one offer in five. In addition, 4% of candidates changed their minds after they had already said yes. This is one agency’s experience in one industry, but the scale is telling.
Candidates rarely apply only to you. According to the Ukrainian tech job board Djinni (April 2026, almost 2,300 hires), at least half of the candidates hired in tech received their offer after 8-35 contacts with recruiters. That’s why it’s worth asking directly whether they are talking to other companies.
A mismatch in terms is no small thing either. In a survey by the Ukrainian job site Work.ua (January 2026, more than 500 job seekers), a gap between the job posting and what the candidate hears in the interview ranked second among the things that frustrate candidates most, right after a lack of feedback.
The cost of a rejection is measured in time: the search has to start over. In Djinni’s report for the first quarter of 2026, the median time from first contact to hire over the past year was 31 days. All that time, the finalist’s work is either done by someone else or not done at all.

Before the offer: what to find out during the interview
An offer shouldn’t contain any surprises, for either the candidate or the company. Everything the answer depends on is settled beforehand: in the final interview or in a short conversation right after it.
- Salary expectations. The amount, the currency, before or after taxes, and how much of it is fixed.
- Start date. How much notice the person has to work at their current job, and whether they have a vacation planned.
- Other companies. Whether the candidate is in final rounds elsewhere, and when those decisions are due.
- What matters besides money. The work arrangement, the schedule, the substance of the work, the future manager.
- What could keep them at their current job. The answer shows whether to expect a counteroffer, meaning a competing offer from their current employer.
- Circumstances it’s better to know about in advance. Relocation, studies, obligations to their current employer.
A check question at the end: “If we offer [amount] on these terms, would you be ready to accept?” It’s better to hear hesitation now than after the letter has gone out.
Record these answers next to the interview scores. How to make a decision on a candidate within 48 hours is covered in a separate article on the structured interview.
What to put in an offer letter: ten points and a template
You need an offer letter even when everything has been discussed verbally: it puts the agreements on record and prevents misunderstandings. Ten points are enough.
- Job title and direct manager.
- Start date.
- Pay: amount, currency, pay frequency, before or after taxes, and bonus terms, if any.
- Type of engagement and contract, for example an employment contract or a contractor agreement.
- Probation period: how long it lasts and the results it will be judged on.
- Work arrangement and schedule: office, remote, or hybrid, and the hours when the person needs to be reachable.
- Vacation, sick leave, and any other terms you discussed.
- Equipment and access: what the company provides.
- The date by which you expect an answer.
- A contact person and what happens after they accept.
A sample letter: “Dear [name], We are pleased to offer you the position of [job title] at [company]. You will report to [name, title]. Start date: [date]. Pay: [amount, currency, pay period, before or after taxes]. Type of engagement: [contract type]. Probation period: [length]. Together, we will write down what we expect from you during this time in a plan for your first 90 days. Work arrangement: [arrangement and schedule]. Vacation and sick leave: [terms]. The company will provide your equipment. Please let us know your decision by [date]. If you have any questions, email or call me at [contact]. Sincerely, [name, title]”
What doesn’t belong in the letter: promises without dates or conditions. “We’ll review your salary based on results,” with no timeframe or criteria, will read to the candidate as a promise of a raise, while the company will see it as no more than an intention. A “flexible schedule” without the hours when the person needs to be reachable ends in an argument in the first month. Write only what you are ready to deliver and what will later appear in the contract.
The probation period clause is the one left out most often, even though it is what shapes how a new hire’s first 90 days go.
Timing: when to send it and how long to wait
Make the offer no later than 48 hours after the final interview, in two steps on the same day: a call first, then the letter. Give two to five business days for an answer. The call lets you hear the reaction and answer questions; the letter puts the terms in writing.
The call fits into five lines: name the position and the amount; name the three main terms; ask which of them matters most to the person; name the date by which you expect an answer; say the letter will arrive today.
- Response deadline. A specific date in the letter, not “whenever you decide.”
- If the candidate asks for more time. Ask what exactly they are waiting for, and agree on one new date.
- On the deadline day. One call or one email. Silence after that is an answer, too.
- The second finalist, while the first one is thinking. Be honest: “We’ll make a decision by [date], and either way we’ll get back to you with an answer.” Don’t turn them down until the first candidate has accepted.
- The second finalist, once the first one has accepted. Honest again: “We’ve made an offer to another candidate. If anything changes before [start date], may we come back to you?”
Why the deadlines are short. In the ITExpert study, the median time candidates took to respond to an offer was two business days. The longer they deliberated, the less often the answer was yes: the correlation between decision time and the answer was minus 0.4, meaning a moderate, inverse relationship.
ITExpert explains it this way: the people who take a long time are the ones who have doubts or are waiting for a counteroffer or other offers. A deadline won’t make such a candidate say yes, but it gives you a date after which you can move on.
Want to see which stage each finalist is at and the messages you’ve already exchanged with them? Request a demo.
Salary negotiation and counteroffers
Before talking about money, you need two reference points: the top of the salary range for this position, and the salaries of the people already working in the same position. The first protects the budget. The second protects you from a situation where a new hire earns more than the people who will be training them.
The top of the range comes from three sources: public salary statistics on job boards for this position, the expectations of candidates who went through your hiring process in the last quarter, and the salaries of your own employees.
If the candidate asks for more than the offer, you have three options.
- The amount is within the range. Agree quickly: long haggling over a difference you can afford spoils the start of working together.
- The amount is above the top of the range. Offer what doesn’t break the range: the start date, the work arrangement, a salary review after the probation period based on documented results. Promise the last one only if you really will review it.
- You have nothing to give. Say so plainly, and keep the offer open until the date you named.
A counteroffer is less likely to catch you off guard if you ask about it in advance. If the candidate tells you about a counteroffer, ask what has changed about the reasons they started looking for a new job. If those reasons weren’t about money, a higher salary at the old job doesn’t remove them. You can improve your offer once, and within the range.
The only data on what happens after a counteroffer comes from the UK. In an Opinium survey for Robert Half (December 2021, 2,000 workers), among those who accepted a counteroffer, 34% still left the company within six months, and 74% within a year.
These are the workers’ own words, and a different country, but the conclusion is useful to both sides: a counteroffer rarely removes the reason the person started looking for a job.
Three things not to do: promise verbally what isn’t in the letter; raise the amount after every “I’ll think about it”; give only a few hours for an answer.
From “yes” to day one
A yes is not the same as a first day at work. Several weeks often pass in between while the person works out their notice at their previous job, and all that time they remain on the market: other companies keep messaging them, and their current employer may make a counteroffer.
Two studies show how often a yes doesn’t end with the person starting work. According to a Gartner survey (third quarter of 2024, about 3,500 candidates), 33% of candidates who accepted an offer later backed out of it. In the 2026 report by the British institute CIPD (791 organizations that tried to hire), 52% of organizations said candidates always, mostly, or sometimes withdrew after accepting an offer, and another 32% answered “rarely.”
Neither study is Ukrainian. There is only one Ukrainian figure: the same 4% from the ITExpert study. Those candidates changed their minds on average 10-15 business days after their first answer. That’s why the weeks before the start date can’t be left without contact.
- On the day they accept. Written confirmation of the terms and the next steps.
- Once a week until the start date. A short check-in from the future manager: department news, questions about getting ready, an invitation to a meeting.
- A week before the start date. The plan for the first week: who will meet them, where and at what time, what the first days will look like.
- Before day one. Paperwork, equipment, access.
- If the person stops responding. A call the same day.
A sample message a week before the start date: “Hi [name], we’re looking forward to seeing you on Monday, [date], at 10:00 a.m. at [address]. [Name] will meet you there. On your first day: meeting the department, setting up your equipment and access, and lunch with your mentor. I’ve attached the plan for the week. See you soon!”
It’s worth recording every offer in one ten-column log: candidate; position; date of the final interview; date of the call; date of the letter; amount offered; response deadline; outcome (yes, no, changed their mind); reason; whether they started work. Take the reason from a closed list, as in the article on the hiring funnel. After five to ten offers, two ratios will show what’s breaking: offers accepted out of offers sent, and people who started out of people who said yes.
Frequently asked questions
How much time should you give a candidate to decide?
Two to five business days, with a specific date in the letter. Less than two days can feel like pressure, especially if the person needs to talk it over with their family. If a candidate asks for more than a week, it often means they are waiting for another offer or a counteroffer, while you keep your second finalist in limbo. Agree on one new date and don’t move it a second time.
Should you name the amount verbally before the offer letter?
Yes. Name the amount and the main terms in conversation and hear the reaction, then send the letter the same day. If the amount first appears in the letter, the candidate reads it alone, without any explanation, and replies the same way: in writing and briefly. In a conversation, you can find out right away what exactly doesn’t work for them.
What should you do if a candidate asks for more than the range allows?
Don’t go above the top of the range for one person: it will affect the salaries of those already working in that position. Offer what doesn’t break the range: the work arrangement, the start date, a salary review after the probation period based on documented results. If that isn’t enough, an honest no is better than an exception you’ll later have to explain to everyone else.
Can you withdraw an offer after the candidate has accepted it?
The legal consequences depend on the country and on whether a contract has been signed. The reputational ones are the same everywhere: the person may have already quit their previous job. To avoid having to withdraw an offer, finish all checks (references, documents, budget approval) before making it. If a condition hasn’t been met yet, state it explicitly in the letter.
What should you do if a candidate accepted the offer and then stopped responding?
Call the same day instead of waiting for the start date. Silence often means a counteroffer or another offer, and a conversation may still change something. If the person doesn’t respond for two or three days, go back to your second finalist. That’s exactly why it was worth telling them you might reach out again.
Do you need an offer letter if everything was discussed verbally?
Yes. A month later, the two sides remember differently what was said about the bonus, the schedule, or the salary review. A ten-point letter settles these disputes and shows the candidate that the company keeps its agreements in order. The template in this article takes a few minutes to fill in, and it should go out on the day of the call.
Keep candidates, your messages with them, and rejection reasons in one place. Free for 14 days.



